2025 MLB odds: Back Yankees to win American League

<!–>

It was a nightmare offseason for the defending American League champion Yankees. 

In early December, free agent superstar Juan Soto traded in his Yankee pinstripes for blue and orange, leaving the Bronx Bombers to go across town and sign with the New York Mets. 

Later in the winter, it was reported that ALCS MVP Giancarlo Stanton had pain in both elbows and wasn’t able to swing a bat. As we enter Memorial Day weekend, Stanton is yet to play and his return is still a good bit away. 

Ace Gerrit Cole was also lost for the season before it began. 

So how are the Yankees in first place by five games as we enter the weekend? 

There isn’t one simple answer. However, there are various reasons why New York looks poised for another deep October run this fall. 

First, Aaron Judge continues to play like an MVP and is ascending to a pace that will put him in the conversation among some of the best players of all time. Also, Judge is surrounded by a deeper supporting cast than he’s had in past years, where the lineup was top-heavy and teams could maneuver around him. 

Former MVP first-baseman Paul Goldschmidt is hitting .337 and has proven to be one of the best signings of the offseason. Outfielder Trent Grisham is having a career year, with 12 home runs in just 131 at-bats. And both players have a chance to be in Atlanta for the All-Star Game this summer. 

ADVERTISEMENT

–>

The rest of the lineup is getting solid contributions from guys like Ben Rice, Jasson Dominguez, and Cody Bellinger, giving the Yankees a deep and balanced offense that leads the American League with 276 runs scored.

While the offseason acquisition of reliever Devin Williams hasn’t worked out so far, Williams has now strung together a stretch of nine scoreless appearances out of his last 10, since being demoted from the closer role in late April. Williams, who has had a sub-2 era in four of his five seasons in the majors, is now a set-up man for closer Luke Weaver, who also looks poised for an All-Star Game selection with a .4 era so far this season. 

The emergence of reliever Fernando Cruz, as well as the return of fellow reliever Jonathan Loaisiga from the IL, gives the Yankees a chance to have a dominant bullpen to go with their league-leading offense come playoff time. Starters Max Fried and Carlos Rodon currently have ERAs of 1.29 and 2.88, respectively, giving the Yankees a formidable one-two punch. 

And it’s likely the team will be aggressive and add talent before the Aug. 1 trade deadline.

Add all of that to the fact that the American League has been largely underwhelming. 

The Orioles have been a playoff team the last two years but don’t have the pitching to compete this year. The Red Sox were a popular pick to make a playoff run but are currently under .500. The Rangers won the World Series two years ago and were co-favorites to win the AL West entering the season, but have struggled mightily on offense and just got swept by the Yankees, currently sitting in third place. 

The Tigers have been a good story and have a very strong team, but the Yankees have dominated AL Central teams in recent postseason appearances and would still be underdogs if they faced the Yankees in a series — despite the brilliance of ace Tarik Skubal. 

At nearly 3-1 odds, with the Yankees’ dominant offense and solid pitching staff, they are a good bet to win the relatively weak American League for a second consecutive year. 

PICK: Yankees (+285) to win American League

Will Hill, a contributor on the Bears Bets Podcast, has been betting on sports for over a decade. He is a betting analyst who has been a host on VSiN, as well as the Goldboys Network. 

Want great stories delivered right to your inbox? Create or log in to your FOX Sports account, and follow leagues, teams and players to receive a personalized newsletter daily!

<!–>



Get more from Major League Baseball Follow your favorites to get information about games, news and more


in this topic

–>

Link to Original Article - on Fox Sports

Bet the Under on Aaron Judge’s home run total for 2025

<!–>

Just five months ago, Juan Soto hit a dramatic, two-out, two-strike, three-run home run to break a 2-2 tie in the ninth inning of Game 5 of the ALCS. 

That helped send the New York Yankees to their first World Series in 15 years.

For Yankees fans, it was as good as it gets — perhaps more than they could imagine at the moment. 

But then, the Yankees lost the World Series to the Dodgers. 

ADVERTISEMENT

–>

They let multiple leads in Game 1 slip away, including being one out away from a win when they surrendered a walk-off grand slam to Freddie Freeman. 

That series ended with the Yankees once again blowing multiple leads, this time in Game 5. In that game, New York led 5-0 in the fifth inning, before multiple errors on seemingly routine plays led to the undoing. That allowed the Dodgers to tie the game. 

The Yankees would pull ahead later in the contest, only to relinquish that lead as well and cost themselves a chance to return to Los Angeles for Game 6.

As painful as the finish to the season was for the Yankees, this offseason has seen the wound of the World Series get treated with a New York-sized dose of salt. 

In December, the aforementioned Soto decided to stay in the Big Apple but switched leagues and teams, signing a mega-contract with the Mets. 

While the Yankees made a handful of widely praised moves in an attempt to offset the loss of Soto, much of the enthusiasm for those moves has subsided. After a rough spring outing, ace Gerrit Cole sought opinions on an achy elbow, culminating in a decision to get Tommy John surgery. 

Cole’s season ended before it began.

Then you have slugger Giancarlo Stanton. He is dealing with not one but two achy elbows, has not participated in baseball activities and has not ruled out getting surgery. Like Cole, surgery would end his season. 

Oh, and reigning AL Rookie of the Year Luis Gil will be out several months with a shoulder injury, and it’s unclear when he will be able to return to the mound. 

So where’s the bet to be made amidst all this doom and gloom?

Certainly, the Yankees missing the playoffs at +200 odds is intriguing, considering what a nightmare winter it has been. If you’re looking for a longer payout, maybe right-handed Yankees pitcher Will Warren — who looks like he will take Cole’s spot in the rotation — is worth a shot to win Rookie of the Year at 15-1, although that number has been slashed since the Cole news broke. 

Of all these, I like Aaron Judge Under 47.5 home runs the most.

Aaron Judge Under 47.5 home runs (FanDuel)

Judge walked a league-leading 133 times last year, and that was in a lineup with Soto and Stanton. With those two guys not near him in the lineup to add traffic and protection like last year, teams will be ultra careful pitching to Judge, making it hard for the reigning MVP to duplicate his incredible numbers from 2024. 

Also, Judge will be 34 in April, and despite being in the league for almost a decade now, he has only had 500 plate appearances four times in his career. 

For a team that has already been bitten by the injury bug, it’s not inconceivable that the big-bodied Judge has to miss a few weeks here and there, which would also strengthen the chances of cashing this Under 47.5 homers bet. 

Without much around him in terms of help in that lineup, and the possibility of injury, betting on Judge to not hit 48 home runs is a wager worth making.

Will Hill, a contributor on the Bears Bets Podcast, has been betting on sports for over a decade. He is a betting analyst who has been a host on VSiN, as well as the Goldboys Network. 

Want great stories delivered right to your inbox? Create or log in to your FOX Sports account, and follow leagues, teams and players to receive a personalized newsletter daily!

<!–>



Get more from Major League Baseball Follow your favorites to get information about games, news and more


in this topic

–>

Link to Original Article - on Fox Sports